The Best Crab Restaurants Near Me in New Rochelle, New York

"First time here with my family who had never tried a seafood boil. The waitress was super attentive, nice, and welcoming. The food was delicious, the portions were perfect and enough for each person. I ordered half a pound of headless shrimp which came with potatoes and corn(big pieces of corn). I ordered extra corn because I like corn however I could not finish it since the orders come with just enough food. Will be returning to try the drinks which looked good too. The place is very big and decorated nicely. Plenty of parking too."

"Fantastic establishment with the hardest working staff who are all so efficient attentive and kind! So respectful and consistent. Our party of 6 enjoyed our visit here and the experience was fantastic. This place is beautiful and clean. The bathrooms were well kept too. Alicia was super great and thoughtful, kudos to her for spectacular customer service. The food was so good and their boba is delicious. The bisque is a MUST! Parking is so good and it’s child friendly but also good for a date or girls night."

"HOLY HEAVEN! My boyfriend and I were craving seafood, and this place delivered. We ordered the fish boat, and it was absolutely incredible—flavorful, perfectly cooked, and generous in portion size. My boyfriend got his with sweet potato fries, and they were seriously delicious. Everything tasted fresh and well-seasoned, and it was totally worth the price. On top of that, the customer service was amazing—friendly and welcoming. Highly recommend... your belly will thank you!"

"Ordered the shrimp and crawfish combo, ate everything down to the shrimp tails. Unbelievably fresh stuff and extremely delicious with great seasoning. The owner was very nice and I'll be back for more this week."

"Nice little place, similar to Johnnys and Tonys on city island. If you are in the mood for city island but don’t want to deal with city island crowds the. This is the spot. They have takeout or outdoor seating. I like this place. The clams were fresh and the food was good as was the service."

"Been wanting to come here for years and finally stop by to have lunch with the family and a long time friend from the area. It was a good choice. All the dishes we had were delicious. The service was very good. The prices were reasonable. A nice option to the madness in City Island. We’ll be back to try some other staples."

"I had brunch with my sister for our March birthdays. I loved it so much! It was our first time here. The service, ambiance/music and food were all 5 stars. We ate the steak and eggs, banana pancakes, chicken (dark and white meat) & waffles, Mac & cheese and a side of bammy. We also had a carafe of White Sangria. For dessert Coconut rum cake with birthday candle. EVERYTHING was delicious; very well seasoned and beautifully played. We wish our stomachs were bigger to try the rest of the menu. We were so full, the serving size was perfect for the two of us. Our server Lloyd was friendly, he gave us some recommendations off the menu and made sure to answer any questions we had about the menu. We appreciate his hospitality. Darien took amazing professional photos of us and even printed one copy for us each. He was very professional and courteous and made us feel like supermodels. We will be back soon. Thank you for a great birthday experience Krave!"

"Great night out with friends, chill vibe, great food and the photographer Kyle was a nice touch. Had the rasta pasta and branzini, both of which were nicely seasoned. Will check out brunch next time! The atmosphere and music was on point."

"I visited Kenny’s on the water a couple weeks ago to celebrate my nephew’s birthday with a group of about 10 people. From the moment we arrived, the staff was incredibly attentive. Marco did an excellent job taking all of our orders and offering helpful recommendations. The food was outstanding — we especially enjoyed the pasta and the steak. We brought an ice cream cake for the birthday boy, and also ordered a few desserts from the menu, which were equally delightful. The manager, Susie, even stopped by our table to ensure everything was going well and that we were enjoying ourselves, which we truly appreciated. I would definitely recommend this restaurant to family and friends. The ambiance is great, and the staff is friendly and professional!"

"The food is absolutely delicious! I typically order the eggplant caprese salad or the Bib and Pear salad followed by Chicken Martini or a pasta dish and eventually closing out with a yummy warm.bread pudding(see picture). The service is good and the manager Susanna is always welcoming to all. Special shout out to the awesome affable server Kimberly who's attentive and engaging with a beautiful smile. Kenny's is not just a great family vibe but also a good gathering space for friends."

"Horrible. The smell I encountered as I removed the fish from the bag was nauseating. It was my first time shopping here and my last. I'm highly disappointed I gave them a try. It's no wonder they have the fish behind a glass where they pick it out...if the public was given the opportunity to smell fish before purchasing.....no one would shop here! I suggest others don't waste their time and money like me."

"This place is superb for fresh fish, frozen fish and deep fried lunch meals. On this visit, I bought frozen lobster tails and fresh bay scallops. Parking can be a little tricky sometimes but it's worth the visit to this little store. Customer service is great. They accept debit cards and the fish is very fresh."

"Oh, the Baltimore Blue Crabs In A Garlic Sauce is the bomb; I always get it. That dish with New England Clam Chowder and a side of baked potatoes is the perfect combo. The rich flavors are so satisfying, and the garlic sauce is the best. Every time I go there, the service is always great, with friendly servers. DIVE SEAFOOD JOINT."

"I had an incredible dinner at The Crab Shanty in City Island! The atmosphere was warm and welcoming, with friendly staff who made us feel right at home. I ordered the filet mignon with lobster tail, and it was absolutely perfect—the filet was tender and cooked to perfection, and the lobster tail was buttery, fresh, and full of flavor. The portions were generous, and everything was beautifully plated. The service was attentive without being overbearing, and you can really tell they take pride in what they do. Whether you're a seafood lover or in the mood for a hearty steak, this place delivers. Definitely a must-visit if you're in City Island!"

"I had lunch with my husband and daughter at this restaurant. The food and drinks were delicious. The ambiance was warm and welcoming, and our server Shayla was very kind. I love the crab fries. It was a hit with everyone. I highly recommend this little spot. Also, they have a kids' menu and a TV available to watch sports."

"This is a neighborhood restaurant I visit at least once every other month. I loved this place and i like rewarding myself with a boil . But I keep noticing these old potatoes everytime I go there since the ending of 2024. I complaint the last time about the potatoes but keep getting the same results with takeout . This Mother’s Day I ordered 2 bags of seafood boil that was so small in size that amounted to $86 , online there is a promotion (spend $66, get fried wings ) I added it and made my purchase just to be told they would not honor what was advertised online because it was Mother’s Day . That was sad and a horrible excuse to not honor what was advertised on the website. Sad to say but I won’t be returning ."

"The atmosphere was pretty good, people having fun, DJ good music, I came to order takeout and took quite a while to be able to put my order in. They had 1 lady doing tables and taking to go orders inside and outside? This was my first time so I definitely was a bit confused. Anyway my food was not how my friend described. I ordered barlic flavor. It had a taste of lemon, some fresh garlic, watery butter and cheese on top??? Idk what I ate. I assumed it was how it comes, sent my friend a picture and she said what the hell is that.I drove all the way from Staten island and I must say I am disappointed and sad city island was closing."

"The food was good and the music is good on a Friday night. The only thing I didn't like that I ordered a Fish 🥣 and asked for it to go and recieved a pouch....what happened to the rest of my drink. It's a young crowd vibe. What we got was not worth $302, that's for sure. I will not be back"

"Everything tasted fresh and wasn't overly seasoned! Great atmosphere with area for children (and adults) to play at, nice spacious indoor and outdoor seating as well. There are ATMs available if you need to withdraw some cash."

"I was told by my colleagues that this was a teacher's place, meaning a restaurant where teachers go to celebrate the last day of school, a momentous occasion, etc. This place had everybody there...teachers, families, younger generation hanging out near the mini arcade. There's music, drinks, seafood, burgers, hot dogs, fries. You can opt to sit inside or outside. Casual wear."

"The food at the Holy Crab is very tasteful. I've had the shrimp and fries, the chicken jambalaya which is delicious and has a good amount of chicken and rice. The drinks here are great too! I recommend the pineapple margarita. My friends and I frequent here for lunch, one of our go to spots! The staff is very nice and attentive as well. The bathrooms are very clean and spacious too."

"Good food and good times at Holy Crab! First time here and had a GREAT time with friends! Seafood smorgasbord! Will be back again! 🥰🤗 Staff was very helpful and fast! Mandy, John (the last man standing 🤗), Ivy and Lisa were the best! I love the Happy Hour menu! Cosmos!!!!!"

"If I can give it 0 stars I would. The crab legs and the scallops were flavor-less. Literally no taste to the scallops like zero seasoning put on it. The shrimp was ok. I ordered the Old Bay sauce but there was no sauce. Just a little bit of old bay water. The potato’s also had no flavor. The corn wasn’t crisp. It was an all around disappointment. The food was mediocre. Even with the old bay seasoning on the food it still tasted like nothing, it’s like that’s literally the only thing they added to the food."

"Wow this food was amazing we order 1lb of the king crab and the snow crab legs with corn and broccoli on the side. The bags came with potatoes and corn already didn’t know that but the corn in the bag is saturated in the sauce I loved it but my mom thought it was too much nonetheless I will be ordering again."